5. Gabrielle, the owner of an apartment building, claimed that Antonio, one of her tenants, did not pay rent for six months. She said Antonio owed her $4,800. The case was heard before a court in Georgia. After both sides presented their arguments, the judge rendered a verdict in favor of Antonio because Gabrielle could not produce a contract stating the amount owed. Gabrielle filed an appeal of the decision because she believed the judge ruled incorrectly.