Did Jean do the right thing in staying quiet and NOT warning the oncoming boat about the reef, rats, or
approaching island? Should he have attempted to warn them and plan for a possible rescue with them?
Why or why not? Was it okay to breach the "oath of the light" and NOT attempt to get the supplies to
rekindle the light? Choose a side and USE SUPPORT (at least two pieces of evidence) FROM THE
STORY! 5-8 sentences.