The sentence that is most likely meant to create suspense for the reader is:
"His name was George, after our nations first president, and he had been the smartest kid in school during his early academic career as well; but George grew up on the other side of the town, so we had really never crossed paths."
In a story, what causes suspense is a situation that makes the reader or viewer wanting to find out more about what transpired in the story.
Suspense usually keeps the reader very much eager to know what happened next in the story line.
Thus, the narrator sets out to tell us that the paths of the two kids where yet to cross, so as a result of that, one will want to know what happens when their paths cross.
Learn more about Suspense on https://brainly.com/question/19988768