Read the following claim:

A flat tax will ensure that all Americans contributes their
fair share, whether they make a little or a lot of income.

Which of these would provide the strongest counterclaim?

A. A flat tax means that everyone pays the same percentage, no
matter how much taxable income they earn.

B. The flat tax is unfairly oppressive to the poor, who spend a larger
percentage of their income on necessities.

C. Citizens are already taxed too much and, therefore, all taxes
I should be eliminated.

D. Any major change to the tax code, such as instituting a flat tax, will
assuredly lead to endless red tape and confusion.