At the beginning of the Euthyphro dialogue, Euthyphro defines piety as "what I am doing now—prosecuting a wrongdoer." Why does Socrates not accept this as a proper definition?

Question

07-02-2020
Social Studies

contestada

At the beginning of the Euthyphro dialogue, Euthyphro defines piety as "what I am doing now—prosecuting a wrongdoer." Why does Socrates not accept this as a proper definition?

Respuesta :

Otras preguntas

What kind of help does the support group american council on alcoholism provide? select one of the options below as your answer: a. it helps friends and family

he equation below represents function a and the graph represents function b: function a f(x) = – 2x 1 function b graph of line going through ordered pairs negat

Historical context can tell us important information about A.) the outcome of the plot B.) the ate of the author C.) the author's bibliography D.) the authors

the__ climates make up the largest climatic zone on earth a) dry b) continental c) polar

Suppose that a large cargo truck needs to cross a bridge. The truck is 30 m long and 3.2 m wide. The cargo exerts a force of 54,000 N. The bridge can only withs

_____ is a favored baroque vocal texture. monody harmony homophony a and c a and b

the theory of evolution does not a. say that populations change b.support the process of natural selection c.describe how species grow into adults d. support ad

during the 18th and 19th century, romantics tried to escape from the new industrial age in all of the following except _____. select the best answer from the ch

Which era spanned from 600 c.e to 1500 c.e

What should you do if a friend were to confide in you about abuse at home?

alejandrahpsi alejandrahpsi · Answer 1 · 2020-02-08T17:11:13+01:00

Answer:

Socrates does not accept this definition because: Euthyphro has merely given an example of an impious act, not a genuine definition that captures the essence of piety in general.

Explanation:

In this dialogue Euthyphro is refering as a piety act, to have to prosecute his own father for the murder of a servant. Being an impious act that a soon has to kill his own father.

Socrates didn't think piety was easily defined. He thought Euthphro could't actually explain what piety was. By saying that "prosecuting a wrongdoer is a piety act", he is describing or giving an axample of it, but it cannot be consider as a proper definition.